Today, the leaders of Carolina Forward and the John Locke Foundation are co-publishing a joint letter to Governor Stein and the members of the North Carolina General Assembly with a shared proposal for the upcoming 2027-2028 legislative session.
Dear Governor Stein and Members of the North Carolina General Assembly,
North Carolina has committed half a billion dollars to the NCInnovation endowment at a time when the state faces substantial competing needs, including continued Hurricane Helene recovery and major infrastructure demands. Permanently committing that much taxpayer capital to a single purpose deserves reconsideration. Carolina Forward and the John Locke Foundation often diverge on matters of public policy, but on this issue we agree: North Carolina lawmakers should reclaim the $500 million NCInnovation endowment and return those funds to the state.
The record
In 2023, lawmakers appropriated $500 million in nonrecurring funds to NCInnovation. NCInnovation reports that it has awarded or committed approximately $37 million to 47 technologies. The overwhelming majority of the original $500 million therefore remains committed to the endowment structure.
Since then, policymakers in both the executive and legislative branches have proposed reclaiming the endowment:
- February 2025: House Bill 154 proposed reclaiming the full $500 million.
- June 2025: The original, bipartisan House budget proposal would have redirected it to Helene recovery.
- 2026: Governor Stein’s recommended budget proposed reclaiming the full amount for the State Emergency Response and Disaster Relief Fund.
None of these proposals became law. The 2026 Appropriations Act (Senate Bill 257) left the endowment intact.
Support for a clawback of NCInnovation’s endowment has spanned both parties, both chambers of the legislature, and Governor Stein. That breadth of consensus is why even organizations like ours, which often do not see eye to eye on many policy issues, can come to common ground on this one.
Where the money could go
While the General Assembly decides where reclaimed funds should go, at least two major areas of need stand out.
- Helene recovery. North Carolina has appropriated more than $3 billion in state funds for Hurricane Helene recovery, yet significant needs remain across western North Carolina, including housing, roads, bridges, and other critical infrastructure. Lawmakers in both the legislative and executive branches, along with public policy organizations, have proposed reclaiming the NCInnovation endowment to support ongoing recovery efforts.
- Rural school facilities. North Carolina’s latest Five-Year Facility Needs Survey identifies nearly $18 billion in school capital needs through 2031, including $9.8 billion in renovations. Nearly half of the projects districts identified involve repairs or deferred maintenance, with additional substantial needs tied to building-code and life-safety requirements and aging HVAC systems. The challenge is especially significant for rural counties with limited tax bases and less capacity to finance major capital projects locally.
North Carolina already recognizes these disparities through the Needs-Based Public School Capital Fund. Reclaimed NCInnovation funds could help address these core public infrastructure needs rather than remaining permanently committed to a research-commercialization endowment.
Five hundred million dollars will not fully meet the enormous cost of Hurricane Helene recovery or North Carolina’s school capital needs. But those are fundamental public responsibilities. The North Carolina Constitution contemplates a state role in responding to emergencies and expressly assigns the state responsibilities for public education. By contrast, maintaining a permanent $500 million taxpayer-funded endowment to support research commercialization is a discretionary policy choice. When homes, roads, and bridges remain unrepaired and rural communities struggle to finance school facilities, we believe those immediate public needs should take precedence.
These are only examples. The General Assembly should determine how reclaimed funds can best meet North Carolina’s most pressing needs through the normal budget process. Our organizations may not agree on every alternative use, but we agree these funds should be available for lawmakers to weigh against the state’s competing priorities.
What we ask
- Reclaim the full $500 million early in the 2027 session, either in the normal budgetary appropriations process, or by standalone legislation if necessary.
- End the existing NCInnovation endowment structure and return the remaining principal to the state.
- Redirect the reclaimed funds toward more pressing public needs, including Hurricane Helene recovery, rural school capital needs, or other priorities determined by the General Assembly.
- Require any future state support for university research commercialization to proceed through regular appropriations, with public reporting, measurable outcomes, and clear legislative oversight.
Lawmakers in both parties have already proposed better uses for this money. The 2027 session is the chance to act on that broad support. Rebuilding communities, restoring critical infrastructure, and helping rural counties meet pressing school capital needs are more appropriate uses of taxpayer dollars than maintaining a permanent $500 million endowment for research commercialization.
Respectfully,
Blair Reeves, Chairman, Carolina Forward
Donald Bryson, CEO, John Locke Foundation